← All posts
Selling online

Etsy or your own shop: is selling on Etsy still worth it?

Every Etsy fee on a real order, whether $10,000 a month is realistic, Etsy versus TpT, and when your own shop keeps more of each sale.

WakatoNovember 21, 2026
Etsy or your own shop: is selling on Etsy still worth it?

Selling on Etsy is still worth it in 2026 if you need buyers you do not have yet, because Etsy brings the traffic. It costs about 10% of each order in standard fees, plus 15% more on any sale Etsy credits to its offsite ads. Once you have customers who come back, your own shop next to Etsy usually keeps more of each sale.

Below is what Etsy really takes, whether $10,000 a month is realistic, how it compares with selling on Teachers Pay Teachers, and when your own shop makes sense. Our example: a candle maker selling 3 kinds of candle at $30 each, plus $6 shipping, about 60 orders a month.

What Etsy charges, line by line

From Etsy's own help pages, for a seller in the United States:

  • A listing fee of $0.20 per listing, charged whether or not it sells.
  • A transaction fee of 6.5% of the order total, including shipping and gift wrap you charge for.
  • A payment processing fee of 3% + $0.25 per order.
  • Offsite Ads: when a sale comes from an ad Etsy ran on another site, a fee of 15% if your shop made under $10,000 in the past 12 months, or 12% once it has. It is capped at $100 per order. Shops under $10,000 can opt out; once a shop passes $10,000 in any 365 days, it is in for good.

For our candle maker, one $36 order (candle plus shipping) costs:

Etsy fees on one $36 order, from Etsy's help center as of November 2026
FeeNormal saleSale from an Offsite Ad
Listing fee$0.20$0.20
Transaction, 6.5%$2.34$2.34
Processing, 3% + $0.25$1.33$1.33
Offsite Ads, 15%None$5.40
Total$3.87 (10.8%)$9.27 (25.8%)

At 60 orders a month that is about $232 in normal fees. If a fifth of the sales come through Offsite Ads, add about $65. The Offsite Ads figure uses the full order total; Etsy describes the base as the sale amount, so your number may come out a little lower.

Is it worth selling on Etsy in 2026?

Yes, for three kinds of sellers:

  • You are starting and have no audience. Etsy's search is the reason people pay its fees.
  • You make handmade, vintage or gift items, which is what Etsy shoppers come to find.
  • You want to test what sells before you build anything of your own.

It is less worth it when most of your buyers already know you (from Instagram, a market stall or your email list). Sending your own fans to Etsy means paying Etsy for customers you found, and Etsy also shows them other sellers' candles on the same page.

Can you make $10,000 a month on Etsy?

Some shops do, but it is the top end, not the typical result. Work backwards before you plan for it. At our candle maker's $36 order, $10,000 a month is about 280 orders, or more than 9 a day. After roughly 11% in fees that leaves about $8,900, before wax, jars, wicks, boxes, postage and your time. Shops that reach that level usually have a few products that rank well, photos that stand out in search, and repeat buyers. Treat $10,000 as a goal you build to over a year or two, and check your profit per order, not only sales.

What items are in high demand on Etsy?

Rather than trust a list, check demand yourself in Etsy's own search: type your product idea, look at how many results there are, which listings carry a Bestseller mark, and what price range those sell at. Good signs are a search with many buyers' reviews on the top listings but only a few shops making something like yours. Personalized items (names, dates, pets) and things bought as gifts tend to do well because the buyer cannot get them in a store.

Is it better to sell on Etsy or TpT?

For teaching materials, Teachers Pay Teachers is the bigger shop, because teachers go there first. TpT has two seller types:

  • Basic: a $29 one-time fee, you keep 55% of each sale, minus $0.30 per resource.
  • Exclusive: $59.95 a year, you keep 77.5% (80% under an offer that runs until January 1), and no transaction fee on orders of $3 or more. You must sell those products only on TpT.

Etsy keeps more of each sale for you (you pay about 10% in standard fees rather than giving up 22.5% to 45%), but teachers rarely search Etsy for lesson plans. A common path: sell on TpT for the traffic, and keep a shop of your own for teachers who already follow you, using non-exclusive products.

Etsy or your own shop?

Most sellers end up with both. Etsy finds new buyers; your own shop sells to people who already know you, at a lower fee, with their email address in your hands. When you choose your own shop, check:

  • The monthly price and the fee per sale, added together at your real volume.
  • Who works out, collects and pays sales tax. Some shop builders leave it to you.
  • Whether you keep the buyer's contact details for a newsletter.
  • Whether it brings any buyers of its own, or only checkout.

Where Wakato fits

Wakato gives you your own shop alongside your website, email list and AI agents. You list a product once and it sells on your pages, your Wakato profile, payment links you send in a chat and, once reviewed, the Wakato Marketplace. Wakato is the merchant of record: it charges the buyer, sends the receipt, holds the money until the buyer has their order, and handles sales tax where it collects it (an extra 0.5% on those sales).

You can sell on every plan. The free plan takes 10% + 50¢ per sale; Pro at $49 a month takes 5% + 50¢; Business at $99 takes 4.5% + 40¢. For our candle maker's $36 sale that is $2.30 on Pro, against $3.87 on Etsy. On the free plan it is $4.10, more than Etsy, so Pro is the better deal once you pass about 31 orders a month; at 60 orders Pro's fees and subscription come to about $187. Every buyer becomes a contact you can email, and an agent can answer shipping questions and send order updates.

The honest limit: Wakato's Marketplace is far smaller than Etsy. It will not replace Etsy's search for a new shop. Use it for the buyers you bring yourself, and keep Etsy for the ones it finds.

Common questions

How much does Etsy take from a $20 sale?

On a $20 order with no shipping charged: $0.20 listing, $1.30 transaction fee and $0.85 processing, about $2.35 in all. An Offsite Ads sale adds $3.

Can I opt out of Etsy Offsite Ads?

Yes, while your shop has never made $10,000 in any 365-day period. After that you are enrolled for the life of the shop at the 12% rate.

Is Etsy good for digital downloads?

It can be, since buyers search there for printables and planners. The same fees apply, so on a $5 download the $0.20 listing and $0.25 processing take a bigger share.

Do I need a business license to sell on Etsy?

Etsy does not ask for one to open a shop, but your city or state may require one. Check with your local government.

Can I sell the same products on Etsy and my own site?

Yes, unless you chose an exclusive arrangement somewhere else. Keep your stock counts in step so you do not sell the last candle twice.

See how selling on Wakato works, or start on the free plan.

The only app you need, run by AI agents.

Website, shop, inbox, phone, ads, social, email, calendar and books in one place. Free to start.

Start free